Skip to content
19 November 2026

Cruz moves FCC pick Thumann forward while Democrats boycott committee

Republican senators approved a Trump‑chosen FCC commissioner despite a Democratic boycott and accusations of false testimony.

Cruz moves FCC pick Thumann forward while Democrats boycott committee

On Tuesday, January 28, 2025, the Senate Commerce Committee convened under the chairmanship of Ted Cruz (R-Texas) and voted to advance the nomination of Danielle Thumann to the Federal Communications Commission. All fifteen Republican members cast affirmative votes, while the thirteen Democrats on the panel were absent, deliberately avoiding a quorum.

Quorum controversy and procedural maneuvering

Cruz opened the hearing by stating, “We’re going to be doing our job today, even if the Democrats refuse to show up to do theirs,” underscoring the partisan tension. Committee rules adopted in 2005 require that a minority member be present for official action on nominations, a point emphasized by a spokesperson for Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Washington). Cantwell’s office noted that the Senate has operated in line with those rules across previous Congresses and that a quorum must include at least one minority member. Cruz’s team, however, referenced broader Senate standing rules, specifically paragraph 7 of rule XXVI, that only demand a simple majority of members physically present, allowing the vote to stand despite the absence of Democrats.

Allegations of misleading testimony

During the same hearing, Thumann testified that she had never worked with FCC Chairman Brendan Carr on any media-related matters. Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-New Mexico) challenged that claim, asking whether she supported Carr’s alleged campaign to silence late-night host Jimmy Kimmel. After the hearing, Luján sent a letter to Cruz asserting that Thumann’s statement was false, citing Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) documents that show her involvement in reviewing media-related issues, including commitments tied to the Skydance-Paramount merger and handling complaints concerning a 60 Minutes interview with Vice President Kamala Harris.

Emails obtained by the group Protect Democracy reveal that Thumann, while serving as senior counsel to Carr, drafted language urging complainants to resubmit their grievances through the FCC’s Electronic Comment Filing System (ECFS). The correspondence references a response to alleged news-distortion complaints about the 60 Minutes segment, indicating she was not merely a passive recipient of information.

Political backdrop and the race for Senate control

Republicans are accelerating Thumann’s confirmation in hopes of securing a three-to-one Republican majority on the FCC before Democrats assume Senate control in January. Cruz reminded the chamber that “Democrats will control the Senate, unfortunately, in January. But today is November 18,” highlighting the urgency of the lame-duck session. While the committee’s internal rules still call for a minority member’s presence, Cruz’s office argued that procedural irregularities cannot invalidate a nomination once it reaches the full Senate floor.

Democratic members, led by Cantwell, appealed to Cruz to cancel the vote, invoking his own 2014 remarks that controversial nominees should not be confirmed in a lame-duck session by outgoing senators. They also stressed the norm of pairing Republican and Democratic nominees when a commission seat from each party is vacant, a practice Cruz dismissed as non-mandatory under the Communications Act. If Thumann is confirmed, the FCC would hold a 3-1 Republican majority, with the lone Democratic commissioner, Anna Gomez, slated to leave at the end of 2027 unless re-nominated.

Author

Evelyn Marks

Evelyn Marks writes about Deep Tech for the readers of this website, covering breakthroughs in AI, quantum computing, advanced materials, and platform technologies. She translates complex research into clear, practical analysis, highlights real-world implications, and helps technologists and business readers understand what advances mean in practice. Evelyn has tracked deep technology developments and collaborated with sector partners to deliver accessible, reliable coverage.