Skip to content
14 July 2026

Evaluating startups with a rigorous scorecard

Discover a comprehensive framework for evaluating deep tech startups, covering key aspects such as trl, ip defensibility, and regulatory risk

Evaluating startups with a rigorous scorecard

Deep tech investing refers to the practice of investing in startups that are developing innovative, cutting-edge technologies. These technologies have the potential to transform industries and create new markets, but they also come with significant risks and challenges. To navigate these risks and identify promising investment opportunities, investors need a rigorous framework for evaluating deep tech startups.

A key aspect of this framework is the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) which assesses the maturity of a startup’s technology. This involves evaluating the technical feasibility of the technology, as well as its potential for scalability and commercialization. By assessing the TRL, investors can determine whether a startup’s technology is ready for investment and potential return.

Evaluating IP Defensibility

Another critical aspect of evaluating deep tech startups is IP defensibility. This involves assessing the strength and breadth of a startup’s intellectual property portfolio, including patents, trademarks, and copyrights. A robust IP portfolio can provide a significant competitive advantage and protect a startup’s innovations from being copied or reverse-engineered. Investors should look for startups with a strong IP strategy and a track record of successfully defending their intellectual property.

In addition to TRL and IP defensibility, investors should also consider regulatory risk. This involves assessing the potential regulatory hurdles that a startup may face, including compliance with industry regulations and obtaining necessary permits and licenses. By evaluating regulatory risk, investors can determine whether a startup is well-positioned to navigate the regulatory landscape and achieve its business objectives.

Market Timing and Manufacturing Readiness

Market timing and manufacturing readiness are also critical factors in evaluating deep tech startups. Investors should assess whether a startup’s technology is aligned with current market trends and demands, and whether the startup has a clear plan for scaling its manufacturing capabilities to meet growing demand. This involves evaluating the startup’s supply chain management and production costs as well as its ability to scale its operations efficiently.

Finally, investors should consider capital intensity modeling which involves assessing the amount of capital required to support a startup’s growth and development. This includes evaluating the startup’s burn ratecash flow and fundraising strategy. By modeling capital intensity, investors can determine whether a startup has a viable plan for managing its finances and achieving its business objectives.

Red-Flag Heuristics and Milestone Design

To further de-risk their investments, investors should also develop red-flag heuristics and milestone design for staged de-risking. Red-flag heuristics involve identifying potential warning signs or risks that may indicate a startup is not performing as expected. Milestone design involves setting clear milestones and benchmarks for a startup’s progress, and adjusting the investment strategy accordingly. By using these tools, investors can proactively manage risk and make informed decisions about their investments.

Author

Beatrice Mitchell

Beatrice Mitchell, Manchester-rooted and classically elegant, famously commissioned a rebuttal series after a controversial council planning meeting in Stockport, insisting on community testimony. Holds a firm editorial line on accountability and narrative fairness, and collects vintage city planning maps as an idiosyncratic hobby.